2006
1st Team
LB – Mike Bowers
Honorable Mention: Shane McCord, Richie Rucker
2005
Honorable Mention: Duke Tate
2004
1st Team
WR – Kendrick Harper
Honorable Mention: Ryan Poole
2003
1st Team
LB – Jae Thaxton
2002
1st Team
LB – Jae Thaxton
2001
1st Team
OL – Justin Berelc
WR – Teddy Craft
LB – Jae Thaxton
Honorable Mention: Duston Ramsey
2000
1st Team
DL – Carlos Bates
WR – Teddy Craft
QB – Jeff Leard
RET – Duston Ramsey
1999
1st Team
DL – Carlos Bates
OL – Phil Blackwell
LB – Patrick Martin
KR – Tino Stowers
P – Jeremiah Van Dora
Honorable Mention: Jamie Burton
1998
1st Team
OL – Jerrell Allen
P – Jeremiah Van Dora
Honorable Mention: Jerrod Moore, Nacomma Maxwell
1996
Honorable Mention: Kenny Hunter, John Thrift
1995
Honorable Mention: Ben Leard, Titus Johnson
1994
OL – Matt Mize
DB – Brian Wilkins
Honorable Mention: Ben Leard